| ||
Visit MustangSteve's web site to view some of my work and find details for: FYIFORD Contributors' PICTURES - Power Brake Retrofit Kits for 65-66 Stangs - Classic Mustang FAQ's by MustangSteve - How to wire in a Duraspark Ignition - Mustang Ride Height Pictures and Descriptions - Steel Bushings to fit Granada Spindles to Mustang Tie Rods - Visit my EBAY store MustangSteve Performance - How to Install Granada Disc Brakes MustangSteve's Disc Brake Swap Page - FYIFORD Acronyms for guide to all the acronyms used on this page - FYIFORD Important information and upcoming events |
1 2 Jump to
Offline
Men,
I have my Father in law's car I'm diagnosing. Drive train out of a 92 mustang GT with AOD. Computer says it's remanufactured. Injectors are not firing. Checked all we know to check. At this point, the PCM is in hand. I'd like to find someone close to diagnose it definitively. I wonder how I'd even find someone to test near me? Also, I'd love to know how to translate the digits on the PCM i'm holding in case I have to buy a replacement. Anyone have a trick for translaating?
I know that's a question that must have come up. Tell me to search harder if need be. Don't wanna be anyone's PITA...
Thanks!
Lance
Offline
Your location would be a good start!
Jus say'in
6sally6
Offline
I don't know of anyone around here that has that kind of equipment. Most shops around here farm that kind of work out. I know the pcm went out in my old Jeep and I sent.off for a rebuilt one in NC. I got one back after a long wait, and it worked for a couple weeks and now I'm dealing with multiple P0 codes. I think they just slapped some paint on it, flashed it, and sent it to me. I did more research and found another place in Florida that I may try it if I just don't give up on it. Now, as for your computer, that is obd1, right? Does it have any test ports, or was all that eliminated. I still have an old obd1 tester, but back then all the cables to each car were different, and I am not sure I have a Ford cable. I seem to remember doing Ford's back then by using a jumper and an analog meter watching sweeps. I think if you want the formal testing though, it's going to have to be sent off.
Last edited by Greg B (1/25/2021 9:24 PM)
Offline
Good to see that you are still around, Lance. Still got that beautiful Vert? Why haven't we seen you since the Vandalia Bash? Just wondering.
1. Was it running with this PCM and then it quit?
2. The label that matters are the big leters on the main connector. Should be A9P or A9M or even A9L if someone has mixed things up. Butt (TS&T), the '92 Stang with AOD should have come with an A9P EEc-IV PCM.
3. If this is the initial fire-up attempt, what harness are you using and are you sure the main EEC relay (hopefully installed) is working. That relay delivers v-power (12 volt) to the PCM and all the injectors and other goodies.
4. The best way to troubleshoot is to try a "known good" PCM. Any of those I listed above will do if you can borrow one.
5 Again, if this is the first go you definitely should run a KOEO (Key On, Engine Off) test first. That will tell you if the PCM is happy with all it's little buddies in the system and that it is talking to them properly.
6. OBD 1 code readers should still be available and not too ridiculous in price. My friend bought one when we EFI'd their Falcon on ebay.
7. You can read the codes without a reader if you have a "Check Engine" light properly wired in and I'm sure you could find the instructions on Gargle or I could email them too you. If there is no check engine light then wire one in. IT'S ELECTRONIC FUEL INJECTION. You need to know when it's not happy.
Last edited by Bullet Bob (1/25/2021 10:07 PM)
Offline
Here's a link for a cheap reader:
Also, PM your email addy to me and I'll send you come copies of good info from a website that was taken down years ago.
Offline
Its largely impossible to test the PCM out of the vehicle. The shops that rebuild them have specialized equipment that can simulate the PCM being in a car. Typically local places just sell a reman PCM.
If the injectors are not firing I would suspect the PCM absolutely last. I've yet to see a bad Ford PCM. Never seen a bad GM one either. Most times they get replaced because its something the guy trying to diagnose a problem suspects due to a lack of understanding of how it works.
How do you know the injectors aren't firing?
Offline
TKOPerformance wrote:
Its largely impossible to test the PCM out of the vehicle. The shops that rebuild them have specialized equipment that can simulate the PCM being in a car. Typically local places just sell a reman PCM.
If the injectors are not firing I would suspect the PCM absolutely last. I've yet to see a bad Ford PCM. Never seen a bad GM one either. Most times they get replaced because its something the guy trying to diagnose a problem suspects due to a lack of understanding of how it works.
How do you know the injectors aren't firing?
My Jeeps alternator went out. More like the voltage regulator. It took the battery and the ecm with it. When I replaced the alternator and battery, afterwards I had the dreaded p0606 code. (Faulty ecm checksum error). This is one of the few codes no one can reset. It still ran fine, but here in Missouri they will not let a vehicle with the check engine light pass emmisions. They no longer check the actual emissions it puts out on obd2 cars. Just the codes. Anyways I had zero choice but to replace the ecm. I searched around the area for someone other than the dealer to try to reflash it, because that was all I believed it needed. No dice. That's when I found the online ecm exchange services. With the new "refurbished" ecm, I now have p0300, p0302, p0304, and p0308 codes. It ran great for a little while until it got cold, so I know it isn't an installation issue, like a bent prong. Nor do I believe that 3 cop's suddenly went out at once. I think it's a moisture issue. It was raining cats and dogs the day it started misfiring. I think the company did open up the replacement ecm to inspect it, but didn't reseal it well. Right now, I'm kind of caught between a rock and a hard place with this thing. But I wanted to make the point, sometimes you DO have to replace a computer. I
Lance, ima head downstairs and see if I have a Ford cable for the auto xray code reader. If I do, you can use it if you like.
Last edited by Greg B (1/26/2021 10:01 AM)
Offline
Ok, I have the Ford cable. I put in fresh batteries it still fires up. If you want to try to use this you can borrow it. If you think it could help. I will even make a road trip to Ofallon, I need outta this house! Lol. Hopes this helps.
Offline
Try pulling codes first.
I would look at ignition coil, TFI, PIP...referring to no injectors firing.
Does fuel pump kick on for a second or two and then stop?
Fuel pump inertia switch tripped?
Offline
Greg B wrote:
TKOPerformance wrote:
Its largely impossible to test the PCM out of the vehicle. The shops that rebuild them have specialized equipment that can simulate the PCM being in a car. Typically local places just sell a reman PCM.
If the injectors are not firing I would suspect the PCM absolutely last. I've yet to see a bad Ford PCM. Never seen a bad GM one either. Most times they get replaced because its something the guy trying to diagnose a problem suspects due to a lack of understanding of how it works.
How do you know the injectors aren't firing?
My Jeeps alternator went out. More like the voltage regulator. It took the battery and the ecm with it. When I replaced the alternator and battery, afterwards I had the dreaded p0606 code. (Faulty ecm checksum error). This is one of the few codes no one can reset. It still ran fine, but here in Missouri they will not let a vehicle with the check engine light pass emmisions. They no longer check the actual emissions it puts out on obd2 cars. Just the codes. Anyways I had zero choice but to replace the ecm. I searched around the area for someone other than the dealer to try to reflash it, because that was all I believed it needed. No dice. That's when I found the online ecm exchange services. With the new "refurbished" ecm, I now have p0300, p0302, p0304, and p0308 codes. It ran great for a little while until it got cold, so I know it isn't an installation issue, like a bent prong. Nor do I believe that 3 cop's suddenly went out at once. I think it's a moisture issue. It was raining cats and dogs the day it started misfiring. I think the company did open up the replacement ecm to inspect it, but didn't reseal it well. Right now, I'm kind of caught between a rock and a hard place with this thing. But I wanted to make the point, sometimes you DO have to replace a computer. I
Lance, ima head downstairs and see if I have a Ford cable for the auto xray code reader. If I do, you can use it if you like.
I wouldn't say they NEVER go bad, but three thoughts about your situation:
1.) I had a P0606 code in my F250. It was a faulty FICM, not the ECU, and after considerable research and understanding of the electric/engine management system it became clear that the FICM failed because I continued to crutch bad batteries. There are some parts in modern electronic engine management systems that require proper battery voltage to operate, and if the voltage is too low they use step up circuitry that can overheat and fail if it isn't addressed in short order. Interestingly, just like my situation this occurred in your Jeep after a battery and alternator went bad.
2.) Jeeps are notorious for coils going bad. Its entirely possible that you have several that are bad. My cousin keeps spares in his glove box the failures are so common. Also, when was the last time you put a set of plugs in it? Its common for bad plugs to throw missfire codes.
3.) Newer computers are also considerably more complicated that the ECU in a '92 Mustang. The simpler an electronic device is the less likely it is to fail. Even given that they are still fairly robust. My main point is that I've seen a lot of ECUs replaced that did not fix the issue. Typically because the ECU is the least understood part of an electrical system that is already the least understood system in a vehicle. When frustration and confusion set in people tend to make up their minds that it must be the black box they don't understand. This leads me to exhaust all other possible causes in a situation like the OP's before concluding that replacing the ECU would fix the issue.
Offline
Thank you all for the opinions, the experience, and the help. We found a place that tests the PCMs. They do work all over the world, and happen to be about 45 minutes from my home. They charge about $89 to "test" the unit with their simulator, and if it needs repair, they will do that for a total of $161.49. We drove ours there, rather than ship it. They will spell out for us whether it is the PCM. Our spectrum of possibilities is pretty narrow at this point.
Offline
TKO,
I believe we have verified that the relays are functioning. I can hear the pump running. I am able to measure rail pressure at 45 PSI. I can see fire from coil, as well as a timing light sensing all 8 plug wires, so the juice is getting beyond the distributor. The injectors have 12v to them, but while cranking the engine over, the voltage doesn't flinch. If I pour fuel in the intake, the car runs. Checked all the grounds I know to check. The PCM has power because the pump runs with the key. This is what has us wondering whether the PCM could be bad. It is a remanufactured PCM already, so someone else apparently had one go bad, or thought they had anyway. I couldn't have gotten this far without help from someone who is pretty car sharp, but I'm eager for your insight. Does what I describe make you wonder about the PCM?
L
Offline
Lance, thanks for the link. I wish I'd have found this place before I went my original pcm to the east coast. I'm going to see if they can solve my problem as well.
That ole Jeep too handy to let go.
Offline
Lance wrote:
TKO,
I believe we have verified that the relays are functioning. I can hear the pump running. I am able to measure rail pressure at 45 PSI. I can see fire from coil, as well as a timing light sensing all 8 plug wires, so the juice is getting beyond the distributor. The injectors have 12v to them, but while cranking the engine over, the voltage doesn't flinch. If I pour fuel in the intake, the car runs. Checked all the grounds I know to check. The PCM has power because the pump runs with the key. This is what has us wondering whether the PCM could be bad. It is a remanufactured PCM already, so someone else apparently had one go bad, or thought they had anyway. I couldn't have gotten this far without help from someone who is pretty car sharp, but I'm eager for your insight. Does what I describe make you wonder about the PCM?
L
No, not yet. Have you verified that you are getting a PIP signal from the distributor to the PCM? Just because it has fire doesn't mean there's a PIP coming from it. This could be a bad TFI module that is throwing spark, but not letting the PCM know its throwing spark. If you have a known good TFI I would change this first.
I would also check the TPS. It sounds crazy, but if the PCM thinks the accelerator is floored it won't command the injectors to fire on start up.
If neither of those work I would get a set of noid lights and check for injector pulse. If it sat for a long time it could be several injectors being clogged and failing to spray fuel. One or two far enough apart in the firing order would still allow it to run, but two right next to each other will not. I had this happen before and after going crazy and trying all kinds of stuff I had the injectors cleaned and the car started right up afterwards.
Offline
TKOPerformance wrote:
Greg B wrote:
TKOPerformance wrote:
Its largely impossible to test the PCM out of the vehicle. The shops that rebuild them have specialized equipment that can simulate the PCM being in a car. Typically local places just sell a reman PCM.
If the injectors are not firing I would suspect the PCM absolutely last. I've yet to see a bad Ford PCM. Never seen a bad GM one either. Most times they get replaced because its something the guy trying to diagnose a problem suspects due to a lack of understanding of how it works.
How do you know the injectors aren't firing?
My Jeeps alternator went out. More like the voltage regulator. It took the battery and the ecm with it. When I replaced the alternator and battery, afterwards I had the dreaded p0606 code. (Faulty ecm checksum error). This is one of the few codes no one can reset. It still ran fine, but here in Missouri they will not let a vehicle with the check engine light pass emmisions. They no longer check the actual emissions it puts out on obd2 cars. Just the codes. Anyways I had zero choice but to replace the ecm. I searched around the area for someone other than the dealer to try to reflash it, because that was all I believed it needed. No dice. That's when I found the online ecm exchange services. With the new "refurbished" ecm, I now have p0300, p0302, p0304, and p0308 codes. It ran great for a little while until it got cold, so I know it isn't an installation issue, like a bent prong. Nor do I believe that 3 cop's suddenly went out at once. I think it's a moisture issue. It was raining cats and dogs the day it started misfiring. I think the company did open up the replacement ecm to inspect it, but didn't reseal it well. Right now, I'm kind of caught between a rock and a hard place with this thing. But I wanted to make the point, sometimes you DO have to replace a computer. I
Lance, ima head downstairs and see if I have a Ford cable for the auto xray code reader. If I do, you can use it if you like.I wouldn't say they NEVER go bad, but three thoughts about your situation:
1.) I had a P0606 code in my F250. It was a faulty FICM, not the ECU, and after considerable research and understanding of the electric/engine management system it became clear that the FICM failed because I continued to crutch bad batteries. There are some parts in modern electronic engine management systems that require proper battery voltage to operate, and if the voltage is too low they use step up circuitry that can overheat and fail if it isn't addressed in short order. Interestingly, just like my situation this occurred in your Jeep after a battery and alternator went bad.
2.) Jeeps are notorious for coils going bad. Its entirely possible that you have several that are bad. My cousin keeps spares in his glove box the failures are so common. Also, when was the last time you put a set of plugs in it? Its common for bad plugs to throw missfire codes.
3.) Newer computers are also considerably more complicated that the ECU in a '92 Mustang. The simpler an electronic device is the less likely it is to fail. Even given that they are still fairly robust. My main point is that I've seen a lot of ECUs replaced that did not fix the issue. Typically because the ECU is the least understood part of an electrical system that is already the least understood system in a vehicle. When frustration and confusion set in people tend to make up their minds that it must be the black box they don't understand. This leads me to exhaust all other possible causes in a situation like the OP's before concluding that replacing the ECU would fix the issue.
I have traced and prodded all the wiring, I am satisfied that isn't the problem. With the replacement pcm, it passed inspection, and ran fine for a while with no problem. The new codes started on a super rainy day driving, right after I got gas. I suspected it was the fuel pump first impression, but that was the first thing I checked and I have a solid 50lbs. I admit I haven't checked each coil yet, but it seems very unlikely to me three going out at once. I'm down to, cam sensor or crank sensor with it throwing no code, or back to the pcm. My Scooby sense tells me that is wherein the problem lies.
Offline
Greg B wrote:
TKOPerformance wrote:
Greg B wrote:
My Jeeps alternator went out. More like the voltage regulator. It took the battery and the ecm with it. When I replaced the alternator and battery, afterwards I had the dreaded p0606 code. (Faulty ecm checksum error). This is one of the few codes no one can reset. It still ran fine, but here in Missouri they will not let a vehicle with the check engine light pass emmisions. They no longer check the actual emissions it puts out on obd2 cars. Just the codes. Anyways I had zero choice but to replace the ecm. I searched around the area for someone other than the dealer to try to reflash it, because that was all I believed it needed. No dice. That's when I found the online ecm exchange services. With the new "refurbished" ecm, I now have p0300, p0302, p0304, and p0308 codes. It ran great for a little while until it got cold, so I know it isn't an installation issue, like a bent prong. Nor do I believe that 3 cop's suddenly went out at once. I think it's a moisture issue. It was raining cats and dogs the day it started misfiring. I think the company did open up the replacement ecm to inspect it, but didn't reseal it well. Right now, I'm kind of caught between a rock and a hard place with this thing. But I wanted to make the point, sometimes you DO have to replace a computer. I
Lance, ima head downstairs and see if I have a Ford cable for the auto xray code reader. If I do, you can use it if you like.I wouldn't say they NEVER go bad, but three thoughts about your situation:
1.) I had a P0606 code in my F250. It was a faulty FICM, not the ECU, and after considerable research and understanding of the electric/engine management system it became clear that the FICM failed because I continued to crutch bad batteries. There are some parts in modern electronic engine management systems that require proper battery voltage to operate, and if the voltage is too low they use step up circuitry that can overheat and fail if it isn't addressed in short order. Interestingly, just like my situation this occurred in your Jeep after a battery and alternator went bad.
2.) Jeeps are notorious for coils going bad. Its entirely possible that you have several that are bad. My cousin keeps spares in his glove box the failures are so common. Also, when was the last time you put a set of plugs in it? Its common for bad plugs to throw missfire codes.
3.) Newer computers are also considerably more complicated that the ECU in a '92 Mustang. The simpler an electronic device is the less likely it is to fail. Even given that they are still fairly robust. My main point is that I've seen a lot of ECUs replaced that did not fix the issue. Typically because the ECU is the least understood part of an electrical system that is already the least understood system in a vehicle. When frustration and confusion set in people tend to make up their minds that it must be the black box they don't understand. This leads me to exhaust all other possible causes in a situation like the OP's before concluding that replacing the ECU would fix the issue.
I have traced and prodded all the wiring, I am satisfied that isn't the problem. With the replacement pcm, it passed inspection, and ran fine for a while with no problem. The new codes started on a super rainy day driving, right after I got gas. I suspected it was the fuel pump first impression, but that was the first thing I checked and I have a solid 50lbs. I admit I haven't checked each coil yet, but it seems very unlikely to me three going out at once. I'm down to, cam sensor or crank sensor with it throwing no code, or back to the pcm. My Scooby sense tells me that is wherein the problem lies.
Plugs? I've had bad plugs throw multiple misfire codes before. Nothing wrong with the coils or the PCM, just worn out plugs.
Possibly the company formerly known as Chrysler builds bad PCMs, I confess to not having a ton of experience with them. Most of the stuff I work on is Ford, GM, Subaru, and Toyota. They all have their own quirks, but with OBDII diagnostics are largely diagnostics.
Offline
I'll be honest, this thing has a one-piece monte-carlo bar and export brace that traps the distributor. I have been trying my best not to have to pull that sucker, (stock shock top mounts suck!), but we did have that sensor in the bottom of the distributor crap out once before. Time to check for the PIP, sounds like.
Offline
$25 to test. But like others, I wouldn't jump to the conclusion that the ECU is bad. Visually, about the only thing you can look for is the condition of the capacitors.
I use the code reader that BB linked to, does everything you need an OBD1 reader to do.
All good info and questions from BB as well. Regarding the harness, if using a modified Fox harness, the salt and pepper shaker connectors are known to be problematic.
A dead TPS with a reading near 5V will make the ECU assume a flooded start attempt, and shut down the injectors. Have you verified no injector pulse with a noid light?
Dan's questions and suggestions are also good. As BB asked, has it ever run in its current configuration?
What exactly have you done to diagnose the problem?
Offline
50vert wrote:
A dead TPS with a reading near 5V will make the ECU assume a flooded start attempt, and shut down the injectors.
I should have known that...just like holding the throttle wide open while cranking...but I didn't. Every time I talk or communicate with you I learn something new, Barry.
Hope we get to see Leonie and you again some day.
'Nuther subject: I sent an email to the "Joe Martin" asking if they would be interested in having some of Ted's models. Waiting for response.
Miss you man, I'll call one of these evenings...noonish your time.
BB1
Offline
Resolution! All the above advise considered, we had delivered the PCM that came with the 92 GT to SIA electronics. We knew ahead of time their workforce was temporarily demolished by mandated quarantines, so instead of their usual 1-3 day turnaround, we would be without for over a week. Without the PCM, I couldn't really check any of the above items. Yesterday morning, I caught wind of a PCM out of a 93 GT AOD and was able to acquire it for $50. I plugged it in, fully expecting that it couldn't possibly be the PCM. But what the heck! Decided to bump the key and check, just for giggles.
To my great surprise, it instantly started! Stunk up the garage because I didn't expect exhaust. Wouldn't stay running without goosing the throttle because I had all the mass airflow stuff disconnected. But once I stuck that back together... voila! I have a running beast once again. Drove it right onto the trailer and took it home.
Just figured you all would enjoy hearing a success story after all of your investment of advice. Thanks, as always. Super helpful group of guys! Love it.
Lance
P.S. If any of your are curious to see what we were playing with, you can find pics here:
Last edited by Lance (1/31/2021 9:22 AM)
Offline
Very good outcome.
Offline
Awesome!
Nice car😎
Offline
Glad the mighty beast is fixed!
Offline
Always a fan when someone posts a resolution to their problem. Strange it was the PCM, but I long ago learned to never say never.
Offline
Finally got a warm enough day after all that mess and did some testing on the Jeep. I first put a noid light on all eight and all eight cylinders were pulsing. Then I decided to check the voltage to all 8 coil on plugs. 4 had 1.9 and the other 4 had 4.99, 5.2, 5.2 and 5.1.
I decided not to mess with the original company I got the replacement pcm from and just ordered another one from another company. Luckily, I took a couple of pictures of the original sticker with the part # on it before I went it back. I hate eating it, but that company has so many negative reviews.... I should have done my homework better. Hey, I got 3000 miles out of it, right?? I'm going to open it up and do surgery on it. I am going to bet I either find moisture in it, or a broken solder joint.
Anyways, I woke up this morning and I got an email that my pcm is already on its way! Less than 24 hr time frame.
And finally, just for good measure, TKO, I splurged, and ordered 8 new coil on plugs and 8 autolite platinum plugs.
1 2 Jump to
REMEMBER!!! When posting a question about your Mustang or other Ford on this forum, BE SURE to tell us what it is, what year, engine, etc so we have enough information to go on. |