FYI FORD - MustangSteve's Ford Mustang Forum
The Internet's Most Knowledgeable Classic Mustang Information
IF YOU HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT CLASSIC FORD MUSTANGS, YOU HAVE COME TO THE RIGHT PLACE!
MustangSteve has over 30 years of Mustang experience, having owned 30 of them and restored several others. With the help of other Mustangers, this site is dedicated to helping anyone wanting to restore or modify their Mustang.... THERE ARE NO DUMB QUESTIONS!!!!!
Visit MustangSteve's web site to view some of my work and find details for:
FYIFORD Contributors' PICTURES - Power Brake Retrofit Kits for 65-66 Stangs - Classic Mustang FAQ's by MustangSteve - How to wire in a Duraspark Ignition - Mustang Ride Height Pictures and Descriptions - Steel Bushings to fit Granada Spindles to Mustang Tie Rods - Visit my EBAY store MustangSteve Performance - How to Install Granada Disc Brakes MustangSteve's Disc Brake Swap Page - FYIFORD Acronyms for guide to all the acronyms used on this page - FYIFORD Important information and upcoming events

You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

7/10/2013 12:58 PM  #1


Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

the battery is in the trunk!!!  I am using heavy duty welding cable to run from the front of the Galaxie to the trunk and it powers the car just fine and starts just fine but when I take a voltage reading at the trunk it only reads 13.5V max.  However if the take the reading under the hood, I get the desired 14.5V.  I wouldn't have thought the cable would have made that much difference but apparently it does.


If it isn't broken...modify it anyway! http://www.DazeCars.com https://galaxieforum.boardhost.com
 

7/10/2013 1:01 PM  #2


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

That is kind of weird.  I would tend to agree with you that the voltage loss in static condition over that distance, especially with those huge copper cables, would not be that much.

How do you have the battery grounded?


Money you enjoy wasting is NOT wasted money... unless your wife finds out.
 

7/10/2013 1:56 PM  #3


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Daze I'm just curious, with that size wire, is it a loss or the battery maintaining its normal voltage. If you have time try this; with the car off measure the battery voltage and the voltage up front. Once again with car off and a small load on (say parking lights) measure the battery voltage and the voltage up front. One maor time with a larger load (Head lights) measure the battery voltage and the voltage up front.This may give you a better feel of the voltage drop or maybe the results will be the same.


If this forum can't fix it, it isn't broke.
 

7/10/2013 2:21 PM  #4


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

I have the same setup with the 3G 130amp Alternator and battery in the trunk.  I get about
13.50 also.   My car always cranks and starts hot and cold so I figure its doing it job.  Usually during the winter I put a trickle charger on it.

Steve69

 

7/10/2013 6:12 PM  #5


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Daze wrote:

the battery is in the trunk!!!  I am using heavy duty welding cable to run from the front of the Galaxie to the trunk and it powers the car just fine and starts just fine but when I take a voltage reading at the trunk it only reads 13.5V max.  However if the take the reading under the hood, I get the desired 14.5V.  I wouldn't have thought the cable would have made that much difference but apparently it does.

is your ground wire the same gauge wire as your positive cable? 


GET HER DONE BULLETBOB!!! ..
 

7/10/2013 6:34 PM  #6


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

from what I've heard, multi strand cable has more resistance than a single core cable. Since welding cable is usually made up of many, many small strands, that could explain the voltage drop.


You can lead a horse to water, but you can't get him drunk
 

7/10/2013 6:35 PM  #7


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Daze wrote:

the battery is in the trunk!!!  I am using heavy duty welding cable to run from the front of the Galaxie to the trunk and it powers the car just fine and starts just fine but when I take a voltage reading at the trunk it only reads 13.5V max.  However if the take the reading under the hood, I get the desired 14.5V.  I wouldn't have thought the cable would have made that much difference but apparently it does.

Fifteen feet of 2 gauge welding cable is not going to create a full volt drop. You have something else going on. You didn't say, but I assume you have the battery grounded to the frame at the trunk area. Based on all the case history I have observed, it is sometimes necessary to run the ground cable back up to the stock location to keep all them little electrons happy. (Yes, 30 feet of 2gauge welding cable costs a lot). You did solder all your connections and cleaned to bright all the fittings?

 

7/10/2013 6:40 PM  #8


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

at wrote:

from what I've heard, multi strand cable has more resistance than a single core cable. Since welding cable is usually made up of many, many small strands, that could explain the voltage drop.

The opposite is true. Electrical current runs on the surface of the wire, so with many wires in the cable there is more surface area which translates to lower resistance and less voltage drop. That is why welding cable is recommended when moving the barpttery to the trunk.

 

7/10/2013 7:44 PM  #9


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

It is odd that you would have a 1v drop however, 13.5v is enough to charge the battery.  As your biggest current draw is the stater, you may want to check the voltage at the starter with the starter motor engaged.  Recommend disconnecting the ignition so it doesn't start.  As long as the voltage is above 9v, you should be OK.
I'd also recommend, as other posts have, of running a heavy-duty ground cable directly to the engine.  The car body/frame does not make the best electrical conductor.


65 Fastback, 351W, 5-speed, 4 wheel discs, 9" rear,  R&C Front End.
 

7/10/2013 9:34 PM  #10


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

MustangSteve wrote:

How do you have the battery grounded?

I have it grounded to the frame.  There is about 2 feet of cable running from the  - on the battery directly to the frame and then another short cable connecting the frame to the engine.

wsinsle wrote:

Daze I'm just curious, with that size wire, is it a loss or the battery maintaining its normal voltage.

The wire is 00 and yes the battery is maintaining normal voltage.


I think the common comment in this thread is the real issue.  I need to add a separate ground wire.  I will get on that and let you know how it comes out.  
 


If it isn't broken...modify it anyway! http://www.DazeCars.com https://galaxieforum.boardhost.com
     Thread Starter
 

7/10/2013 11:00 PM  #11


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

You are using 00 welding cable!!! Why didn't you tell us you won the lottery!

 

7/11/2013 7:17 AM  #12


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Daze, glad to see you did it right.  We also used 00 welding cable on our cars....on both the positive and negative, and we did not have the voltage drop you are showing. 

I must say, I have never had a battery last so long in a car, getting the battery away from the heat in the engine compartment was the best thing in the world for it.

 

7/11/2013 8:12 AM  #13


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Hornman wrote:

You are using 00 welding cable!!! Why didn't you tell us you won the lottery!

Didn't win the lottery at the time... this was probably 8 or 9 years ago the price of 00 was not that bad I think I paid less than $1.00 a foot.  I know it is way more than that now.  I am thinking of leaving the battery grounded to the frame and then running a smaller (still heavy gage welding wire) cable as a secondary ground.  The smaller cable would be easier to run and a little easier on the pocket book.  I guess we will see when I go to the welding store to price cable  


If it isn't broken...modify it anyway! http://www.DazeCars.com https://galaxieforum.boardhost.com
     Thread Starter
 

7/11/2013 3:49 PM  #14


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

The un-asked question is where is your alternator picking up the voltage for the voltage sense wire? Should be yellow with a white tracer on the stock connector (labeled A). If you want the battery to have 14.5 volts, that wire would need to be run back to the battery. If you are dumping the alternator under the hood at the old starter solenoid, then that would mean that the alternator would probably be putting out 15V under the hood. To get around this you would have to run the sense and charge wires to the trunk. 14.5 to the battery, and 13.5 to the engine bay.

All things considered, 13.5 is probably fine for keeping your battery charged considering how well the 1G alternator performed that it replaced!

BobN

 

7/11/2013 9:22 PM  #15


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

BobN wrote:

The un-asked question is where is your alternator picking up the voltage for the voltage sense wire? Should be yellow with a white tracer on the stock connector (labeled A). If you want the battery to have 14.5 volts, that wire would need to be run back to the battery. If you are dumping the alternator under the hood at the old starter solenoid, then that would mean that the alternator would probably be putting out 15V under the hood. To get around this you would have to run the sense and charge wires to the trunk. 14.5 to the battery, and 13.5 to the engine bay.

All things considered, 13.5 is probably fine for keeping your battery charged considering how well the 1G alternator performed that it replaced!

BobN

Aaaaghhh, thats the question I should have asked!!!! The real question to be answered. Whenever I do electrical work the voltage sensing is the key design parameter. Its official, I have CRS!!!

 

7/12/2013 7:23 AM  #16


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

The plot thickens.  Yesterday I fired it up and the alt light flickered for a few minutes then went out.  Then when I got to my dads, I couldn't get it started.  We put a charger on it that shows % charged and it was sitting at 10%  The more I think about it I have something else going on other than the battery being in the trunk.  Before I swapped out the engine It ran and charged fine for a whole driving season the way it is set up.  I have a theory as to my problem but will not mention it until I get a chance to test it.

As to BobN's question about the charging light the alt is wired in to the stock harness. 


If it isn't broken...modify it anyway! http://www.DazeCars.com https://galaxieforum.boardhost.com
     Thread Starter
 

7/12/2013 11:00 AM  #17


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Maybe you having something drawing down the current from your Battery Daze?

Steve69

 

7/13/2013 2:53 PM  #18


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

I did a bunch of tests yesterday and I think there are several things going on.  First of all after fully charging the battery I checked voltage with the engine off and no load and there was hardly any voltage drop at the battery compared to under the hood.  As I added a load (engine still off) the difference between under the hood and at the battery increase but was still less than 1V difference.  Then I started the car and repeated the tests I had already done.  At first voltage was good around 14V then as I added a load and it dropped.  At one point it was below 12V then the sound of engine changed slightly and the voltage jumped up to 13.5V.  I bought the alternator used and I am thinking there may be an issue with the regulator.  Another possible issue is improper grounding.  When I had the car running two seasons ago the alternator bracket was bare aluminum.  when I rebuilt the engine I had the bracket powder coated.  Even though my meter says I have good continuity between my alternator and the engine block with no resistance, I am thinking the ground is insufficient.  My plan is to ground the alternator directly to the block and then see if that helps make things more consistent.  I will then look in to running a ground wire from the block all the way to the battery and adding a voltage sensing wire to go from the battery to the alternator.  If all that seams to work than fantastic, but if I am still having issues I will have confirmed it to be the alternator/regulator.  Either way I have a new alt ready to take its place once I work the bugs out and get things set up correctly.


If it isn't broken...modify it anyway! http://www.DazeCars.com https://galaxieforum.boardhost.com
     Thread Starter
 

7/13/2013 4:39 PM  #19


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Daze wrote:

I did a bunch of tests yesterday and I think there are several things going on.  First of all after fully charging the battery I checked voltage with the engine off and no load and there was hardly any voltage drop at the battery compared to under the hood.  As I added a load (engine still off) the difference between under the hood and at the battery increase but was still less than 1V difference.  Then I started the car and repeated the tests I had already done.  At first voltage was good around 14V then as I added a load and it dropped.  At one point it was below 12V then the sound of engine changed slightly and the voltage jumped up to 13.5V.  I bought the alternator used and I am thinking there may be an issue with the regulator.  Another possible issue is improper grounding.  When I had the car running two seasons ago the alternator bracket was bare aluminum.  when I rebuilt the engine I had the bracket powder coated.  Even though my meter says I have good continuity between my alternator and the engine block with no resistance, I am thinking the ground is insufficient.  My plan is to ground the alternator directly to the block and then see if that helps make things more consistent.  I will then look in to running a ground wire from the block all the way to the battery and adding a voltage sensing wire to go from the battery to the alternator.  If all that seams to work than fantastic, but if I am still having issues I will have confirmed it to be the alternator/regulator.  Either way I have a new alt ready to take its place once I work the bugs out and get things set up correctly.

Isn't it normal as a load is placed on the battery for the voltage to drop some, just as long as it doesn't drop too low at idle to the point where its discharging?  You mentioned that the engine sound changed, could that be that the idle went up? which would increase alternator pulley revolutions, which would increase voltage? I'm really not seeing anything wrong here yet.  Do you have underdrive pullies?
 


GET HER DONE BULLETBOB!!! ..
 

7/13/2013 8:45 PM  #20


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

MarkinSC wrote:

 Isn't it normal as a load is placed on the battery for the voltage to drop some, just as long as it doesn't drop too low at idle to the point where its discharging?   

Absolutely.  Voltage drop is to be expected as loads increase.  The interesting thing I noticed was that the bigger the load the bigger the discrepancy between the voltage at the battery and the voltage under the hood.  and then I did get the voltage to drop below 12V just before the change in engine sound when it jumped back up.

MarkinSC wrote:

You mentioned that the engine sound changed, could that be that the idle went up? 
 

The sound was more like the engine having to work harder as if the alternator "kicking on" caused more drag on the engine.

I still think is has more to do with pore grounding and or an old alternator that may need to be replaced


If it isn't broken...modify it anyway! http://www.DazeCars.com https://galaxieforum.boardhost.com
     Thread Starter
 

7/13/2013 9:55 PM  #21


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Just curious about a couple of things.  Are you using the gen light as the "sensing" wire?  If you are, did you plumb a resistor in series with the light so if the bulb goes out the alt will still charge?  

The other thing I was wondering about, is how did you deal with the yellow battery wire at the Galaxie's voltage regulator?   If I remember correctly, there was some wires and the horn relay, that were put on the same junction lug, that needed direct battery voltage.   I will have to pull out my schmatic.  I believe I had to run a wire from the battery to those two wires when I eliminated the voltage regulator.  

correct me if I am wrong here, but the 3g is a 3 wire hookup, no?  One large to the battery, one sensing wire that basically goes to the battery also that "reads" the voltage, and the third wire that goes to the battery charge light.   That wire is what actuates the charge.  If the voltage errrr.  gen light (we are talking Galaxies here, LOL)  bulb fails, the alt will not charge correctly.   That is why the resistor gets put in there.  

What is the battery voltage reading with everything off?   12.6?   If it is, it sounds like its charging, just not aggressively.   I think your problem lies in the excitor wire to the gen light.  


 

Last edited by Greg B (7/13/2013 10:00 PM)


If multiple things can go wrong, the one that will go wrong will be the one that causes the most damage.
 

7/13/2013 9:57 PM  #22


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Daze wrote:

MarkinSC wrote:

 Isn't it normal as a load is placed on the battery for the voltage to drop some, just as long as it doesn't drop too low at idle to the point where its discharging?   

Absolutely.  Voltage drop is to be expected as loads increase.  The interesting thing I noticed was that the bigger the load the bigger the discrepancy between the voltage at the battery and the voltage under the hood.  and then I did get the voltage to drop below 12V just before the change in engine sound when it jumped back up.

MarkinSC wrote:

You mentioned that the engine sound changed, could that be that the idle went up? 
 

The sound was more like the engine having to work harder as if the alternator "kicking on" caused more drag on the engine.

I still think is has more to do with pore grounding and or an old alternator that may need to be replaced

I think as BobN said, the sensing wire is in the front of the car and not near the battery, so the alternator isn't really getting a fair reading as to the condition of the battery to respond properly by letting the regulator push more amps thru. 

                            


GET HER DONE BULLETBOB!!! ..
 

7/15/2013 7:07 PM  #23


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

Daze - suggest you look at MAD Electric, good info on 3-wire alternators, Generator-Alternator conversions and voltage sensing ... http://www.madelectrical.com/


65 Fastback, 351W, 5-speed, 4 wheel discs, 9" rear,  R&C Front End.
 

7/25/2013 1:06 PM  #24


Re: Figured out why I was only getting 13.5V out of my 3G alternator

UPDATE  

I replaced my alternator and that made a big improvement.  I am now getting 13.9V at the battery at idle with nothing on and it only dropped down to 13.17 with both the headlights and my electric fans on.  Also the alt light doesn't flicker at start up, it just goes out.  Next step is to run the sensing wire back to the battery.  That should really improve things.


If it isn't broken...modify it anyway! http://www.DazeCars.com https://galaxieforum.boardhost.com
     Thread Starter
 

Board footera


REMEMBER!!! When posting a question about your Mustang or other Ford on this forum, BE SURE to tell us what it is, what year, engine, etc so we have enough information to go on.