FYI FORD - MustangSteve's Ford Mustang Forum
The Internet's Most Knowledgeable Classic Mustang Information
IF YOU HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT CLASSIC FORD MUSTANGS, YOU HAVE COME TO THE RIGHT PLACE!
MustangSteve has over 30 years of Mustang experience, having owned 30 of them and restored several others. With the help of other Mustangers, this site is dedicated to helping anyone wanting to restore or modify their Mustang.... THERE ARE NO DUMB QUESTIONS!!!!!
Visit MustangSteve's web site to view some of my work and find details for:
FYIFORD Contributors' PICTURES - Power Brake Retrofit Kits for 65-66 Stangs - Classic Mustang FAQ's by MustangSteve - How to wire in a Duraspark Ignition - Mustang Ride Height Pictures and Descriptions - Steel Bushings to fit Granada Spindles to Mustang Tie Rods - Visit my EBAY store MustangSteve Performance - How to Install Granada Disc Brakes MustangSteve's Disc Brake Swap Page - FYIFORD Acronyms for guide to all the acronyms used on this page - FYIFORD Important information and upcoming events

You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

11/13/2020 7:47 AM  #1


Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

I have a buddy that is considering using the Holly Sniper setup on a 4.7L dodge. He has a Shelby truck he loves, and an old work truck with the same engine, carbureted, that sucks wind. He has been looking for a kit that will allow him to tune it. Anyone have opinions?

Thanks guys,

Lance

 

11/13/2020 12:15 PM  #2


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

A buddy at work swapped a LS into an 80 Corvette and used the Sniper for the port fuel injection. He likes it a lot. The car runs really well too. 

I was looking at the version they have for 2x4 throttle bodies..... ideas for down the road. 


John  -- 67 Mustang Coupe 390 5 speed
 

11/13/2020 1:22 PM  #3


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

I know virtually nothing about the Chrysler EFI systems, probably because they decided to sit the '80s and '90s out as Ford and Chevy duked it out on the street.  So I'd approach it like adding EFI to anything where EFI wasn't available from the factory.  A complete kit is the way to go in that scenario.  I can't recall hearing anything bad about the Sniper, and plenty of good, so I'd say go for it. 

 

11/13/2020 4:59 PM  #4


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

There's a great forum / blog for the sniper. Most problems people experience is from failing to read the install die-wreck-shuns....

Good place to visit first and research. Be advised, a couple guys on that forum will bark at cha if you ask a question that's been answered and archived 100 times.

 

11/15/2020 12:25 AM  #5


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

Thanks guys!

     Thread Starter
 

11/17/2020 2:24 PM  #6


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

I was wondering about EFI kits such as these and question whether these systems are going down the road of making a simple car more complex? EFI is something I think about in the years to come, but...


1964-1/2 D Code Coupe - 289 V8, 4 Speed Toploader, 3.00 ratio rear, Autolite 4100 Carb, 15" tires, Pertronix ignition
 

11/18/2020 6:30 AM  #7


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

It depends on what you are used to working on, and the system you are working on.  Good EFI does a lot of self diagnostics.  Then generally you just need a multimeter and the know how to use it.  Initially a lot of carb guys were resistant to EFI, but ultimately  think they didn't really know how to tune carbs all that well either. 

 

11/20/2020 3:22 AM  #8


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

TKOPerformance wrote:

It depends on what you are used to working on, and the system you are working on.  Good EFI does a lot of self diagnostics.  Then generally you just need a multimeter and the know how to use it.  Initially a lot of carb guys were resistant to EFI, but ultimately  think they didn't really know how to tune carbs all that well either. 

I have only ever had classic cars with carbs, so installing an EFI system and setting it up seems a bit daunting. I am sure I could work it out and it is just a matter of learning something new. I do wonder how much is involved in converting from a 4 barrel carburetor to an EFI. Is this a day's work, or is it much more involved than that. Also, what might be the rough total cost to install EFI?
 


1964-1/2 D Code Coupe - 289 V8, 4 Speed Toploader, 3.00 ratio rear, Autolite 4100 Carb, 15" tires, Pertronix ignition
 

11/20/2020 6:34 AM  #9


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

Toploader wrote:

TKOPerformance wrote:

It depends on what you are used to working on, and the system you are working on.  Good EFI does a lot of self diagnostics.  Then generally you just need a multimeter and the know how to use it.  Initially a lot of carb guys were resistant to EFI, but ultimately  think they didn't really know how to tune carbs all that well either. 

I have only ever had classic cars with carbs, so installing an EFI system and setting it up seems a bit daunting. I am sure I could work it out and it is just a matter of learning something new. I do wonder how much is involved in converting from a 4 barrel carburetor to an EFI. Is this a day's work, or is it much more involved than that. Also, what might be the rough total cost to install EFI?
 

It depends on the system you use.  There are self contained EFI systems now that bolt in place of a carb and require minimal wiring and no tuning.  You will have to make some changes to the fuel system as carbs and EFI operate at radically different fuel pressures.  Typically you will have to add a return line back to the tank with EFI, unless the system uses deadhead style fuel delivery, but these systems are hard on the fuel pump, and though OEMs flirted with them, all have since abandoned the idea due to concerns about reliability.  You can buy an EFI ready tank, sending unit, etc that will bolt in due to the popularity of the Mustang. The guys who go this route want EFI with the minimum of fuss, don't mind if they leave a couple HP on the table, don't have time to mess with it, and cost is less of an issue than ease of installation. 

On the other end of the spectrum you can convert to the EECIV system used on the Fox Mustangs using either Speed Density or Mass Air and gain the ability to tune the system via software and a laptop.  Swapping the mechanical parts of the EFI is relatively simple, and you will have the same fuel system concerns, though the wiring is considerably more involved.  Then there's the tuning aspect.  The factory system is actually quite good and will run almost any engine you put it on (excluding forced induction applications, unless you modify it accordingly), but to optimize it you need to tune it or have it tuned. The guys that go this route typically want the most out of their engines, don't mind learning a new skill (if they don't already know it), and have plenty of time to mess with it.  There can also be a considerable cost savings going this route if you for example buy a used engine that already has all the EFI hardware on it. 

 

11/20/2020 7:46 AM  #10


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

If I switch to EFI, I think I will go with one of these set ups. Mounts in the factory location, reuses the factory supply line and does not need a return line.  Looks like it makes the switch to EFI as simple as possible.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=10xrBib8p6g

 

11/20/2020 8:13 AM  #11


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

Chaplin wrote:

If I switch to EFI, I think I will go with one of these set ups. Mounts in the factory location, reuses the factory supply line and does not need a return line. Looks like it makes the switch to EFI as simple as possible.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=10xrBib8p6g

No offense but, if "simple as possible" is what you are looking for I recommend you simply leave a pot on it.  Maybe go to a Edelbrock or just leave an Autolite 2100....simple, works fine and lasts a long time.

BB1

Last edited by Bullet Bob (11/20/2020 8:14 AM)


"you get what you pay for, good work isn't cheap, and there are NO free lunches...PERIOD!"
 

11/20/2020 9:45 AM  #12


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

How about simple and effective? 

What potential issues do you see with that set up?

 

11/20/2020 10:27 AM  #13


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

Chaplin wrote:

How about simple and effective?

What potential issues do you see with that set up?

Are you asking what issues do I see with aftermarket injection?  Well, I run the Ford system, which was no problem at all until I started messing with it.  Then I had to negotiate the "learning curve".  But if you a going to run relatively stock the EEC-IV system with Mass Air and the A9L, M, or P computer is pretty hard to beat...and relatively cheap.  The biggest issue will be wiring but factory harnesses can be cut, chopped, re-routed, and made to be very reliable, regardless of what some will tell you.  Or, with not too much effort you can buy some good wire and make up your own P&P harness to run the engine in an otherwise stock car.  The fuel system will need to be dealt with regardless but that doesn't need to be high buck rocket science either...just a bit of time and an external Walbro pump...I've been running one all over the country for over ten years and 35K miles.
I just don't see any reason to spend $2500+ on something that can be put together for less than half of that and will run as well or better.

JMO

BB1
 


"you get what you pay for, good work isn't cheap, and there are NO free lunches...PERIOD!"
 

11/20/2020 10:33 AM  #14


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

I bought a FiTech system in 2016.  It worked really well for about 3 years then the gremlins hit.  Random shut downs.  Then wouldn't start.  There tech department was horrible.  I decided to pull it and use a Summit Racing Carburetor that works really well.  If I was going to do it again I would go with a Edelbrock  Pro flow 4 system.  Maybe in a few years they'll have all the bugs worked. out.  My feeling is if my car shuts off and I have a hand held computer is should throw a error code with what the problem is.  Like a newer car that has EFI.  These systems don't do that.  You could spend days adjusting settings and this and that and still not fix the problem.   If you break down your screwed.  There's no way you'll figure out whats going on.  This last summer I ran out of gas because of faulty gas gauge.  Took my 5 minutes to figure that out with my carburetor that I had a fuel problem...LOL  . Steve69   

Last edited by Steve69 (11/20/2020 10:35 AM)

 

11/20/2020 10:35 AM  #15


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

No, I was just wondering about potential issues with that Holley fuel pump set up. It seems like a very simple way to plumb your system to convert from carb to EFI, regardless of which EFI system you use.

 

11/20/2020 2:35 PM  #16


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

Interesting setup, but there's a couple things in that video I can tell you are simply not true.  That setup is not going to be as good or reliable as a baffled tank.  I know how the hydromat setup works and if you push the car and require a lot of fuel it gives you a small reserve while you wait for the tank to slosh back over it, but that's not going to work under hard cornering, braking, or accelerating.  A baffled tank is a much better solution, preferably one with a sump in which the pickup sits.  OEM tanks have been like that since the late '80s.

I see the way its done so it doesn't require a return line, and while its simple; its not ideal.  The problem is that the system is bypassing fuel BEFORE the fuel rail(s).  This is NEVER going to be as good a proper return regulated fuel system.  It puts the injectors at risk under high demand conditions.  Fuel pressure is non adjustable as it would be with a proper vacuum referenced regulator.  59psi can actually be too high depending on the injector style.  EV-1 injectors for example are designed to work at 38-45 psi and going much higher causes issues with atomization and efficiency is lost. 

So cheap?  Yes.  Effective?  Sure?  Long lasting and on par with an OEM style system?  Not even close.  Think about it, if this worked so well the OEMs would be doing it right now.  Let's be honest, its a lot cheaper than running two fuel lines and a vacuum referenced regulator.  The OEMs messed with this kind of system in the late '90s, early '00s and went back to return regulated systems because of reliability issues. 

 

11/20/2020 4:14 PM  #17


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

I can see myself staying with a carburetor for a long time to come. Surprisingly, this discussion has made me realize that a well tuned carburetor is the simplest.


1964-1/2 D Code Coupe - 289 V8, 4 Speed Toploader, 3.00 ratio rear, Autolite 4100 Carb, 15" tires, Pertronix ignition
 

11/20/2020 6:55 PM  #18


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

No argument that proper baffling is better than the hydromat and that OEM is superior in terms of design and long term reliability, but I guess the question is....is that set up "good enough" to run reliably on one of our street driven classics for 10s of 1000s of miles such that the benefits of the ease of installation and set up outweigh the benefits that come with having the comparatively more complex but overall superior OEM type installation?  I guess we need some guinea pigs to test it out and let us know how it works long term.

Interesting video comparing a carb and Sniper on a 289, FWIW.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=M2u7d8kajVI

 

11/21/2020 6:59 AM  #19


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

Here's the real question: how do you use your Mustang?  If you stay local and only take short trips then maybe its worth the gamble.  If you take the longer trips a lot of us have gotten into with our cars then I say its in no way worth it because you aren't going to drain the gas tank and swap a fuel pump (that you likely won't find locally anyway) on the side of the road.  That story ends in an unplanned overnight or several day stay, a tow bill, a garage bill, etc.  To me its just not worth it.

I'll also add that the OE type system is not any more complex than any fuel system on any car truly built for power.  Every fuel system I've ever built for a vehicle designed to make real power (north of 400) has used a bypass regulator with a return line whether it had a carb or EFI.  Once you start making serious demands on the fuel system a return regulated system has a lot of benefits, even for a carb.  One of the big ones is that it keeps the fuel cool.  It likewise takes the load off the fuel pump, and whether its electric or mechanical that's always a good thing for longevity.  Then there's keeping consistent pressure at the carb's needle and seat, which ensures no issues with the float(s), no fuel spewing out the vents, etc.  A regular OEM system is fine for a stock or lightly modified engine, but when you start looking to double OEM output these are things that start to become important.

 

11/21/2020 8:10 AM  #20


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

To answer the question about use of the car, right now I don't use it for anything other than trips up and down my street until I finish it😀. But once it's done, its duty will likely be limited to trips within a 3 or 4 hour range of the house. I'd love to take a cross country trip in it some day and attend a Bash, but realistically,  I am probably at least 6 or 8 years away from being able to do that with the current demands on my time from work and kids. Although if I did take a trip across country, I would travel with a number of replacement parts like a fuel pump (regardless of which type of fuel  system I used), ignition module for the distributor, coil, fan belt, etc., so that any breakdowns could be fixed on the side of the road and not leave me stranded for days waiting for replacement parts to arrive. 

Unless you went with an external pump or mounted your pump in the top of the tank and ran the fuel lines through the trunk (which does not appeal to me, although I know a lot of people do it), you will have the same issue with needing to drain the tank to change the pump, so I don't see that as being a huge negative to this set up.

It sounds like the biggest drawback to this set up is the potential for shorter pump life due to the lack of a return line?

So, to avoid draining the fuel and to ensure maximum pump life would you suggest an external pump with a return line like BB's set up?

 

11/21/2020 5:32 PM  #21


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

Chaplin wrote:

But once it's done, its duty will likely be limited to trips within a 3 or 4 hour range of the house.

Although if I did take a trip across country, I would travel with a number of replacement parts like a fuel pump (regardless of which type of fuel  system I used), ignition module for the distributor, coil, fan belt, etc., so that any breakdowns could be fixed on the side of the road and not leave me stranded for days waiting for replacement parts to arrive.

I read this with some curiosity... It sounds like you are scared to drive the car? I feel that if you rebuild the car, replace the worn out and suspect components, then it should be about as reliable as a late model vehicle. Cars are cars and they all run the risk of something going wrong, no matter what the year is or make of the vehicle. About the only thing I would ever carry with me is a back up Pertronix module. Other than that, I wouldn't give it a second thought and you always have plenty of parts stores if something ever did go wrong. That is what I think anyway...
This discussion on EFI has really swayed my thinking to stay with a carburetor. I drive my car frequently, but it is not an everyday driver. For the use it gets, I think I can live with a carburetor and keep things simple.

Last edited by Toploader (11/21/2020 5:33 PM)


1964-1/2 D Code Coupe - 289 V8, 4 Speed Toploader, 3.00 ratio rear, Autolite 4100 Carb, 15" tires, Pertronix ignition
 

11/21/2020 6:06 PM  #22


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

Nah, not scared to drive it, just like to be prepared in case something breaks on the road. I like the idea of being able to do simple fixes on the side of the road and getting back on the road without needing a tow.  Fuel pumps fail (electric probably more so than mechanical), coils die and it seems Pertronix ignition modules fail with some regularity.  All of those parts are small and are easily replaced quickly with simple tools. I'd rather carry those parts in my trunk and not need them than have them crap out when I was 100 miles from nowhere and not have them.

It's sort of like carrying a spare tire. You might never need it, but having it and not needing it is better than needing it and not having it.  Sure, you don't need to carry a spare because there is always AAA and tire stores around, but I'd rather change my own tire and be back on my way than wait on the side of the road for a tow truck to bring me to a tire shop.

 

11/21/2020 7:36 PM  #23


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

Someone on here a few years ago said that his "emergency kit" consisted of an empty credit car, a charged cell phone, and a AAA card.  Makes good sense and I nearly embrace that line of thinking...still have to pack a few incidentals on the Bash trips.

As for driving it...well, somewhere on here is a pic of our Heap and Glens 65 5.0 at the top of Pikes peak back in 2011.  Both were equipped with EFI and neither behaved any differently at 14115 than at the lower elevations.  I'm pretty sure your dribble pot wouldn't be as friendly.
The other thing I recall about that trip was the guy with the temperature gun at the bottom.  They wouldn't let you leave the park if the brakes were too hot.  I just rode down with the AOD in 1st gear and he checked my front brakes three times...couldn't believe that old car could have brakes that cool.
That was also the trip (To the Kalispell Bash) were Glen was gonna pull in for gas "at the next spot, I promise".  We finally stopped in Rawlins and my twenty gallon tank took 18.5.  I guess I had the fuel pickup adjusted just about right.  Modern mesh pick-up screen, stock tank, no baffles, external fuel pump.

BB1
 


"you get what you pay for, good work isn't cheap, and there are NO free lunches...PERIOD!"
 

11/22/2020 7:34 AM  #24


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

The drawbacks are not just shorter pump life.  Shorter injector life is also part of it.

As far as a pump goes I greatly prefer an in tank pump.  An OEM style pump should last 100k+ (I've had them go over 200k in some applications).  In tank pumps are quieter and seem to last longer because they are cooled by the fuel.

As far as reliability goes with these older cars.  They should be able to be just as reliable as a new car, if fact probably more reliable due to the lower level of complexity (less stuff to go wrong).  That said, its all about the skills of the person doing the rebuilding.  We've all been let down by something we did that wasn't quite right, etc.  Its part of the learning experience.  But I can tell you that I long ago learned not to do something I knew was marginal or not the best way to handle something.  That stuff bites you in the @$$ every time. 

Last edited by TKOPerformance (11/22/2020 3:57 PM)

 

11/22/2020 2:17 PM  #25


Re: Anyone have experience or opinions about a Holly Sniper EFI Masterkit?

TKOPerformance wrote:

But I can tell you that I long ago learned not to do something I knew was marginal or not t best way to handle something.  That stuff bites you in the @$$ every time. 

Got that right! Some things I am just happy to pay the money and get it done right, by someone that knows how to do it.


1964-1/2 D Code Coupe - 289 V8, 4 Speed Toploader, 3.00 ratio rear, Autolite 4100 Carb, 15" tires, Pertronix ignition
 

Board footera


REMEMBER!!! When posting a question about your Mustang or other Ford on this forum, BE SURE to tell us what it is, what year, engine, etc so we have enough information to go on.